Shoplifting Couple Jailed for eBay Toy Sales

A California couple that bragged on national television about shoplifting toys — which included Lego and Star Wars-themed toys — have been sentenced to more than a year in prison each after being busted selling the hot goods on eBay. Matthew and Laura Eaton were indicted in September, more than a year after they appeared […]

screen-shot-2010-03-23-at-33134-pm

A California couple that bragged on national television about shoplifting toys -- which included Lego and Star Wars-themed toys -- have been sentenced to more than a year in prison each after being busted selling the hot goods on eBay.

Matthew and Laura Eaton were indicted in September, more than a year after they appeared on the Dr. Phil show bragging about their escapades. They told viewers they earned about $3,500 per week selling the goods they pilfered from outlets surrounding their suburban San Diego home.

The 27-year-old woman was sentenced to 366 days imprisonment. Her 34-year-old husband got 27 months on Monday.

Using eBay user IDs such as "meeaton75," welcomemat75" and "matt_hts," the defendants informed their online eBay clientele they lawfully obtained the toys from "distributors," according to the one-count conspiracy indictment (.pdf).

The indictment alleges that in August 2008, they hijacked a Star Wars Millennium Falcon toy from a Target near their home, where the authorities discovered 500 other boxes of stolen toys. In all, the authorities said the two sold about $100,000 worth of shoplifted toys on eBay between 2006 and 2009.

According to a transcript of the Dr. Phil show that aired November 2008, Dr. Phil McGraw asked the husband: "Are you lazy?" Eaton replied: "Probably."

When issuing the sentences Monday, U.S. District Judge Irma Gonzalez "went off" on McGraw, who was not at the hearing.

According to the San Diego Union-Tribune:

"What a charlatan this man is," the judge said during the hearing. "What a terrible, terrible man." Gonzalez was perturbed that McGraw holds himself out as a doctor wishing to help. But, the judge said to Matthew Eaton, "he obviously didn’t help you." Matthew Eaton's lawyer said the couple went on the show seeking help for their chronic shoplifting problem. On the program, however, they came across as bragging about their exploits and not appearing particularly troubled.

See Also: