Sega's NFL 2K video-game series has always been a potential Hall of Famer. So when the company acquired the ESPN license in 2003 after former contract holder Konami fumbled the ball, audiences rejoiced.
But then, a bunch of puzzling events occurred that didn't bode well for the title. The release date of the latest version, ESPN NFL 2K5, was moved up to July 20 – three weeks before archrival Madden NFL 2005's planned debut. Shortly thereafter, the game's suggested retail price unexpectedly dropped to $20. Then it was announced that Take Two Interactive's budget label, Global Star Software, would co-publish the title.
As it turns out, though, the more aggressive release date and the cheaper price have more to do with undercutting Madden NFL 2005 than the quality of NFL 2K. This title is a superb gridiron simulation that easily justifies the season ticket cost.
For starters, there's the game's dynamic TV-style presentation. The spirited pre-game setup is delivered by sports announcer Chris Berman, which sets the mood. Multiple viewing angles highlight every bone-crunching tackle as sideline reporter Suzy Kolber watches the action. The fluid, dynamic commentary mirrors the on-field action nicely.
Look closely and you will spot fans cheering and waving foam fingers from the stands. Numerous cut-scenes and animations (athlete injuries are handled especially adeptly) add nuance. Character models exhibit polish too. For example, they execute laterals or assault ball carriers with more finesse than in past series installments. There's also a nice touch with in-game celebrations: Cheeky champions can commemorate victories with personalized dance steps.
But it's the representations of passing and punting plays that deserve a Super Bowl ring. Handling is responsive, if somewhat unrealistic (action-arcade fans likely will enjoy the simple presentation better than stat freaks). For example, while on defense, the system lets you try to force fumbles at the risk of letting the ball carrier get away. Everything said, the gimmick works well, and ensures neophytes won't have a problem getting into the game.
Also worth noting is that the challenging computer opponents point toward solid artificial intelligence routines. A rivalry with the console feels thrilling for the effort. But don't worry about the computer kicking your ass too hard – there is a personalized handicapping system to match everyone's ego.
Here's how the system works: You can record the tendencies of your opponents, human or computer, on a memory card so that you can scrutinize their strategies later. The resemblance between re-creations and real-world counterparts is uncanny. As a result, underdogs who practice with the system can actually get a leg up on friends.
Now the verdict. While worth cheering about, ESPN NFL 2K5 ultimately can't contest Madden NFL 2005's reign. Pulled in many directions by a "more is better" mentality, this year's contender feels less polished than its chief competitor. Developer Visual Concepts' labor would've been better spent doing less, yet doing it with greater finesse.
On the bright side, it will surely get another shot at stardom. Given some extra time at training camp, this promising rookie could evolve into MVP material.
ESPN NFL 2K5 is available now for the Xbox and PlayStation 2 for $20. It is rated E for everyone.
