Road Test: The Scooter Showdown

SEGWAY VS. RAZOR We all heard the hype about Dean Kamen’s Segway (née Ginger, née IT): It will indelibly alter our transportation paradigms! It will transform our lives more than the Internet! Now that we’ve seen it, four words come to mind: really expensive Razor scooter. Call it Kamen’s worst nightmare, but we did the […]

SEGWAY VS. RAZOR

We all heard the hype about Dean Kamen's Segway (née Ginger, née IT): It will indelibly alter our transportation paradigms! It will transform our lives more than the Internet! Now that we've seen it, four words come to mind: really expensive Razor scooter. Call it Kamen's worst nightmare, but we did the only logical thing - side-by-side test-drives.

NAME SEGWAY HUMAN TRANSPORTER

LIST PRICE $3,000 to $8,000

WEIGHT 80 lbs

CARRYING CAPACITY 250 to 325 lbs

TOP SPEED 12.5 mph

RANGE 11 to 17 miles

PORTABILITY Turns into a powered hand truck that can be yanked up a flight of stairs.

STEERING Moves where you lean, seeming to sense the direction you're going.

COLLISION CONTROL Backs up when you hit something.

SAFETY RATING Won't cause harm to body parts or objects it runs over.

TARGET MARKET Warehouse workers, postal employees, forest rangers, and eventually, urban dwellers.

UNDER THE HOOD A network of digital signal processors with gyroscopic sensors that monitors the rider's center of gravity 100 times a second.

CURB APPEAL I think, therefore I move.

NAME RAZOR-E ELECTRIC SCOOTER

LIST PRICE $400

WEIGHT 30 lbs

CARRYING CAPACITY 220 lbs

TOP SPEED 10 mph

RANGE 6 to 8 miles

PORTABILITY Folds up for easy carrying.

STEERING Minimal.

COLLISION CONTROL Motor stops automatically when you hit the brake.

SAFETY RATING Pedestrians beware.

TARGET MARKET Consumers, ages 16 an dup.

UNDER THE HOOD There ain't one: WYSIWYG.

CURB APPEAL Skateboarding for the geriatric set.

MUST READ

Stop the Flu in One Breath
Return to Sender
Download Your Cell Phone!
People
They Know You're Lying
A Storybook Ending
Online at Sea
Jargon Watch
Road Test: The Scooter Showdown
An Underground Pipe Dream
Bloomberg's Virtual Wall Street
How a Copyproof CD Works
Peripherals, LiteBrite-Style